
Before I start, yes I have read the graphic novel of Watchmen, and yes I plan to talk about it at length within this post. I’m fully aware of my incapability to write a review for the average unacquainted moviegoer. Each frame of the almost-three-hour film was involuntarily compared to the panels of a graphic novel which provided a comprehensive visual outline.
That being said, I will give Zack Snyder one thing — the man knows how to create a visually spectacular movie. He’s still not a “visionary director,” but he’s definitely not a hack either. For the most part, he truly manages to recreate the Watchmen universe on-screen. He just happens to lack any sense of subtlety. Over-the-top, slow-motion fight scenes when the original comic barely showed any action at all? Check. Ozymandias’s character blatantly foreshadowing the ending? Check. Not that I was at all surprised by the former, and going in I knew the latter was ruined by the casting of a pencil-necked effeminate actor.
According to Wikipedia, even the actor had doubts:
“I was very worried about my casting,” Goode says, believing that he was “not the physical type for [Ozymandias].
Snyder should have taken heed. Ozymandias is supposed to be a wise, middle-aged, perfect physical specimen of a man — not a young, thin guy with a vaguely homosexual German accent. Oh, and the music choices were embarrassing. That would be part of the lack of subtlety.
Getting those critiques out of the way, I had way too much fun seeing the comic on the big screen. Dr. Manhattan’s origin story was handled brilliantly, Rorschach kicked an amazing amount of ass, and the Comedian was just as hilariously fucked up as he is in the graphic novel. Nite Owl and Silk Specter were the least interesting in the original comic, and that doesn’t change in the movie. I didn’t find Silk Specter’s acting as offensive as some critics seemed to, but that’s probably because I never cared about the character in either the book or the movie. So with Snyder managing to totally nail three out of the six main characters, and Nite Owl not being half-bad either, that brings the character batting average to .667. Respectable.
I wanted to make the beginning of this post the section for anyone who hasn’t read the graphic novel (most people), but I seem to be already comparing the movie to the book in every aspect. I do think the movie works on a basic superhero movie level, and I recommend a watch if you can stomach excessive, stylized violence and one truly terrible love scene, but it’s no substitute for the graphic novel. It’s a shame that Snyder had to try to fit so much into less than three hours of film, but I think he created as faithful an adaptation as we were ever going to get. It’s also unfortunate that such an adaptation only serves to solidify the argument that the comic would’ve worked better as an HBO mini-series, but I’m not complaining about what we got. The movie at least managed to delve far enough into the characterization of Rorschach, Dr. Manhattan, and the Comedian, even if the plot is condensed and compromised. I only wish more people read the book beforehand.
Only continue if you wish to read spoiler-filled rambling about both the movie and the book.
read more…